Best Spincast Reels: Squashing Your Misconceptions About Spincasters

Last Updated on May 6, 2021 by Coty Perry

Best Overall

Zebco Omega Pro

4.7/5

Best Premium

Zebco Bullet

4.7/5

Best Budget

Pflueger President Spincast

4.5/5

Spincast reels? Aren’t those for kids? Well, yes – but not always. A lot of reel manufacturers give spincasters a bad reputation because they pump out these bottom-dollar, crappy reels and sell them at Wal-Mart for ten bucks. 

That doesn’t mean that all spincast reels are like that. Some of the most respected reel manufacturers on the planet produce the best spincast reels that are well worth your time and money. I’ve fished some terrible ones but I’ve also fished some great ones. 

In this guide, we’re combing through to find the needles in the haystack when it comes to spincast reels. I think you’ll be pleasantly surprised.

7 Best Spincast Reels: Reviewed

Zebco Omega Pro Spincast

BEST OVERALL

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Zebco Bullet Spincast Reel

Best Premium

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Pflueger President Spincast

Best Budget

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Pflueger Trion

Best Triggerspin

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Zebco 33 Gold

Best for Saltwater

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Zebco Micro 33 Triggerspin

Most Beginner-Friendly

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

KastKing Brutus

Honorable Mention

SPECIFICATIONS
BENEFITS
DRAWBACKS

Understanding Spincast Reels

parts of the best spincast reels

If you’re on the fence about what type of reel you should purchase, the following sections should help you make that choice. Going with a spincast reel over an ultralight spinning reel or standard spinning reel requires you to understand the different components of each and why anyone would pick one over the other. Let’s go in-depth on the topic and break down the details of the top spincast reels. 

Closed Spool – The Good 

The first and most obvious thing you’ll notice about spincasters is that the spool has a cover over it that protects the line and internals from wind, water, and sun rays. If you’re just introducing yourself to fishing for the first time, this has it’s pros. 

You don’t have to worry about tangling your line because there’s a lot less chance of anything going wrong. The line runs along the spool and out through a small opening at the top of the cone. 

Since the line isn’t flowing so freely in open air, the chances of getting tangled are lower as long as you understand how to properly cast. 

Another plus of having a cone around the spool is the fact that it will prevent debris from getting inside. While things can get in and line can get tangled, the chances of it happening are smaller with a spincaster. 

This is one of the reasons why most anglers will always say that spincasters are for beginners. What you lose in performance, you gain in user-friendliness. They’re also easier to care for and take care of because the cone protects everything and increases the lifespan of the reel in most cases. 

Of course, this won’t always apply. But in general, the lifespan of a spincasting reel is longer than most other reels in the same price range. 

Closed Spool – The Bad 

Now for the bad news about a closed spool. Again, these are primarily my opinions so you may have a different experience. 

Casting with a closed spool is naturally more difficult because there’s more abrasion and more touching points along the way. As a result, it slows down your cast and makes it more difficult to hit the spot you want. 

This is another reason why most anglers wouldn’t be caught dead with a spincaster. They’re primarily geared towards beginners and weekend warriors who might be on the water killing time and they’re not worried about whether or not they catch anything. 

Another issue I have with a closed spool is that things can happen inside and it makes it more difficult to catch it before it becomes a big problem. Some of the worst tangles I’ve had have come with these types of reel because you aren’t able to see it coming. Then you need to take the lid off, untangle everything, and put the lid back on. 

Push-Button

push button on the best spincast reels

Another thing that is different about spincasters in comparison to baitcasting reels and others is the use of a push button on most. You’ll mount a spincast reel on the top of the blank like a baitcaster and it comes with a button on the bottom that you’ll depress with your thumb. When you’re ready to cast you’ll release the button and the line will start flowing off the spool. 

When you’re ready to engage the line again, you’ll start cranking the handle. This operation is much simpler than using a spinning reel or baitcasting reel and it limits the number of errors that can occur along the way. That chances of something going wrong are slim but there are also some issues you can run into. 

I find that casting with push button reels requires more precise timing than spinning reels simply because it’s a mechanism you’re relying on rather than your finger. 

With a spinning reel, you release your finger that’s pressing down the line and you cast, it’s simple. With a push button reel, you need to release your finger from the button which then releases the line inside so it’s an extra step. When you add extra steps, you increase the chances of running into a problem. 

Triggerspin

Triggerspin spincast reel

If you’re not a fan of the push button but still want to get a spincaster, you could go with a triggerspin design. These mount on the bottom like a standard spinning reel and instead of using a button, they come with a trigger that operates similar to a spinner as well. 

You’ll press the trigger down when preparing to cast, release it when you do, and then crank the handle to engage the line again. The process is basically the same and still requires mechanism to release and engage the line but I personally prefer triggerspin casters because they’re more closely related to spinning reels. 

I also trained my kids on triggerspin reels because I didn’t want them to get into the habit of pushing a button to cast. The process of pressing the trigger mimics how you’ll fish when you open the bail and press the line against the blank. 

Take-Up Pins 

The most important component of a spincasting reel are the take-up pins. These act like the bail of a spinning reel and control the engagement of your line. When you push the button, the take-up pins will release the line and when you start cranking they will engage the line again. 

You want to pay attention to all mentions of these in the reviews above because the durable and performance of your take-up pins will make a huge difference in the overall performance of the reel. Sometimes the pins can wear down and they won’t properly engage the line which will result in trouble retrieving. 

Other times the mechanism designed to release the line doesn’t work properly and that’s even more frustrating. The result is your line stopping dead in the air and your lure flying half way across the pond or worse (wrapping around and flying back at you). 

Look for materials like graphite, aluminum, and ceramic versus plastic. These will last longer and provide better performance over time. 

Casting and Retrieving 

We always talk about smoothness when it comes to casting and retrieving. Every angler wants a reel that casts smoothly, engages the line properly, and reels back as smooth as it went out. That’s something we all want but not something we all get. Some premium offerings will feature a multi-disc drag, ball bearing drive, and full metal body which is something you won’t find in the cheaper spincasters on Amazon. 

When it comes to even the best spincast reels, they have their limitations in this area. I find that casting with a spincaster is difficult and frustrating because you can’t get the same distance you would on any other reel and retrieving can be a challenge as well because they’re not usually as quick to retrieve slack line as some other reels would be. At that point, you might as well just use them as an ice fishing reel

That said, there are some that are a league above the rest and the seven reels reviewed above are exactly that. As long as you take care of them, you won’t even notice the difference between casting with those and casting with a spinning reel.

Buying Factors of the Best Spincast Reels

bass caught with the best spincast reels

Now that you understand the limitations of spincast reels, let’s talk about some of the factors I consider when purchasing one.

Durability 

The durability of a reel is important but even more important with spincasters. The reason many people purchase this type of reel is because they’re looking for something that will last a long time and they may not use it as frequently as they would a spinning rod and reel. As a result, you need something that won’t rust, break down, and become temperamental over time. 

That requires you to choose very carefully. If you choose the wrong spincaster, you’re going to end up with a reel that operates poorly and starts to give you trouble after a year or so. 

I recommend going with a reel with as much metal and stainless steel as possible especially on the take-up pins. You also want to pay attention to the ball bearings and whether or not they’re shielded. Many spincast reels do not come with shielded bearings which makes it easier for debris to get inside and make casting and retrieving difficult. 

Weight 

Many people who choose this style of reel are looking for something with ease of use. I personally purchase spincasters as backup reels and for friends who want to fish but don’t have their own gear. Because of that, I need something that is super easy for them to use and if the reel weighs 20 ounces, it’s going to be heavy, clunky, and they’ll get tired of holding onto it after a while. 

You should also keep in mind that fishing with spincasters is typically an ultralight game which will require a lot of presentation on your part. If you’re jigging or tossing topwaters, you’ll get tired very quickly with a heavy reel. 

As a result, pay close attention to the weight and anything heavier than 15 ounces is excessive unless you’re fishing saltwater. 

Design 

The overall design of the reel is obviously an important factor. Do you like the push button or trigger action reels better? As I’ve said, I prefer the triggerspin design simply because it closely mimics what I’m used to with a spinning reel. I also think it’s important to teach youngsters on that type of reel as well so it primes them as they progress and move away from spincasters. 

On the flip side, push button reels are great for people who might not have such an easy time fishing. Those with disabilities or painful bones and joints may prefer the push button reel because it’s easier to use and doesn’t require as much movement in your hands. 

You also want to pay attention to the handle on your reel. Most spincasters have a standard angle aluminum handle with one paddle but some have two. I find the two paddle design nice for cranking but it’s not always necessary.

FAQs

There’s a few different reasons. First, they chew up your line because of the way the pins are designed and from the abrasion. Second, they have an inferior drag in comparison to most other reels. Third, they’re not as smooth and can’t offer the same level of casting distance and accuracy. Even with the best ultralight spincast reel in the world, you’re still going to face severe limitations.

Absolutely, you can use pretty much any reel for catfish because the presentation isn’t very elaborate and catfish aren’t that finicky. Bottom feeders will be a lot less choosy about what they bite. There are specific catfish reels though that I would recommend for large channel cats.

Underspin is another word to describe the triggerspin design. They call it underspin because the reel sits underneath the fishing rod blank like a spinning reel.

Final Thoughts

If you’re trying to choose the best spincast reel I hope this guide has helped you make an informed decision. There’s a lot of misconception out there about these types of reels and I made sure to be as brutally honest as possible. 

Will you face limitations with spincast reels? Yes. But, that doesn’t mean they don’t have their time and place on the water. 

If you’re a beginner, looking for a backup reel, or trying to find something that is simple and easy to use, this is the way to go. Consider any of the options above and be sure to leave me a comment and let me know how you made out. Tight lines!

Exclusive Insider Content!

Latest Fishing News, Gear Reviews, and Expert Advice to take your fishing to the next level.